A huge amount of enterprise IT happens in the cloud now, and public cloud spending continues to grow year on year. Most of that is infrastructure and management, with only a proportion being applications delivered as Software-as-a-Service. Which raises the question: when "everyone" consumes their IT as SaaS, do we still need companies that "just do" software development?

The case against in-house software dev

The logic against it seems pretty convincing. Companies don't want to carry the cost of big internal IT teams any more, and with no IT team there's no obvious call for in-house, bespoke development either. Buying packages for on-premise use means installation, debugging, patching, upgrading, and who wants that hassle when a market-leading cloud solution can do 99% of what you need, turned on or off as you wish?

All I know is this: we get approached constantly for "traditional", pre-cloud software engineering by corporate IT departments. That suggests that even though SaaS is huge, the need for independent outside coding help hasn't gone away. So what is SaaS not giving them?

"For twenty years we've been building systems that deliver competitive advantage"

Cloud is absolutely a factor in today's enterprise ecosystem, and nine times out of ten, the systems we build or extend will end up hosted in the cloud. But they won't be purchased from it. Cloud doesn't mean you need to get everything from it, and it's still not where you go for anything beyond a fairly vanilla package for heartland systems like finance or HR.

For over twenty years, through all of the cloud hype, we've been building enterprise systems used by a single client that deliver exactly what they asked for: competitive advantage. Clients tell us they can't get that advantage from the same solution everyone else uses. A package might do 80% of what they need, but that final 20% is the most important element. It's what lets a company do things no one else can, and even if the software we write is hosted in the cloud, it's still their bespoke system, unique to them.

UK software development is alive and well

SaaS is, by definition, a lowest common denominator approach; you have to offer a vanilla set of functions to get the economies of scale that make building it as SaaS worthwhile in the first place. Independent software development remains alive and well, especially in industries like pharma, and the UK software development industry continues to grow steadily year on year.

A final objection we sometimes hear is that you can get code cut more cheaply by going offshore. That's fine if you're prepared to manage the process closely. But you can't just call a software company abroad, tell them what you want and expect to get what you actually meant; there's a layer of interpretation that gets lost. We've seen clients go offshore, watched it go pear-shaped, and take years to put right. A software development partner needs to understand your business as well as, or better than, you do, and remote development often just doesn't deliver that.

Most enterprise workloads still haven't fully transitioned to the cloud. Every time we meet a new client, we tell them: get the standard applications by SaaS if you can, but for the real competitive differentiator, the thing you simply can't get from the market, an expert software house working with you remains the best option.